Tuesday, 23 November 2010

Exercise One Brainstorming

As stated in the previous blog, Exercise One is for me to create some unique game concepts based around existing game mechanics. The first thing I did was brainstorm as many games with interesting/unique game mechanics I could think of onto a piece of A3 paper. I tried to avoid obvious mechanics found in a broad range of games and stick with ones that are mostly exclusive to the title they are found in.

From the brainstorm I picked several different mechanics that sounded like they had enough weight to base a game concept around. I collected some reference images from each game and compiled them together below.


MORPH BALL: From the Metroid series (specifically Metroid Prime), the player has the ability to transform into ball allowing them to roll around the environment, access smaller areas and rolls up ramps. The Morph Ball also has the ability to drop bombs and climb 'spider tracks' to reach otherwise inaccessible areas. I picked this mechanic because I liked the idea of switching from first person perspective to third person when you control the Morph Ball. The Morph Ball was almost a game within itself, the controls and abilities were completely different from the regular mode and it gave the environments a completely different perspective. Conceptually I also like the idea you turn from a character/human into an object almost, often using the morph ball as a object or conduit in complex mechanism in the environment.

OCTOCAMO: Based on an octopus' ability to change it's appearance to blend in with it's environment, Metal Gear Solid 4 gave the player a special auto-camo suit which would change it's texture to blend into the surface the player was leaning against. The core concept of Metal Gear Solid is stealth and the player would use the octocamo to blend seamlessly into the walls, floors and objects of the environment to sneak past guards undetected.

MASKS: Majora's Mask's central theme was 'masks' the player would collect throughout the game which would help them beat dungeons and solve quests. When worn masks would transformed the player into a totally different character, with new moves and advantages to get around the world. I usually find games with 'transforming' mechanics pretty uninspired but Majora's Mask managed to get it right and all the main masks were useful and more importantly, fun to use.


GAME SPEAK: From the Oddworld series, the player character of the game, Abe, uses 'Game Speak' to communicate with members of the same species as himself. Buttons are assigned which allowed Abe to shout commands to other characters, including 'Follow me', 'Wait' and 'Work'. Using game speak the player must guide Abe and his friend to escape portals avoiding the enemy NPCs who too, have their own unique game speak which they use to talk to one another.

BRUSH TECHNIQUES: The Celestial Brush, was the one of the most prominent mechanics in the PS2/Wii game 'Okami'. At any time during the game the player could use brush techniques to fight enemies, bloom flowers and trees or alter the environment. This could including painting stars in the sky, manipulative water and fire or change the environments from night to day.

PORTALS: As the title suggests, Portal's unique mechanic revolves around the Portal Gun with the power to shoot an entrance and exit portal anywhere in the environment. The Portal Gun was used to solve small environment puzzles usually contained to one or two indoor rooms. The player could send objects or themselves through the portals in order to reach the exits.

The next steps for exercise one is to take these six mechanics and brainstorm some scenarios and different obstacles these mechanics could be applied to in the process creating some unique game concepts based around them. I will then select the mechanics with the most interesting scenarios and take them on to the next step of the project.

Sunday, 21 November 2010

Semester 1 Objectives

My key area of study this semester has been the relationship between mechanics and level design. These two subjects are the fundamentals of game design and what makes a game a game. Mechanics are useless without the player being able to apply and cause a reaction with those tools and levels can’t even be considered a game until the player can have some input and cause a reaction in the game universe. Last month I did a quick exercise of performing reverse level design on some existing popular video games. The purpose of it was to see how easy/difficult it would be to map level designs so they could be read by anybody else on a team. So really the three keywords this semester for my work are communication, mechanics and level designs. All three equally important as one another.

From my objectives I sought to find a method where I could apply and learn these skills. I suggested in an early blog some possible ideas. The two that have stuck with me are:

Exercise One: Create a unique game concept based around an existing mechanic from an existing video game.

Exercise Two: 
Take an existing video game and create a unique mechanic that can be used within the game. Demonstrate the unique mechanic in a detailed level design for that game.

These two exercises are good ways to explore both ends of the mechanic-level design relationship. In exercise one the thinking revolves more around the level/game design my work is going to take place in. In exercise two the mechanics are the starting point and the levels are to be designed around those mechanics. Both exercises will be useful as they let me to both express my creativity whilst at the same time working under constrains. At the end of the semester I will hopefully have examples of both exercises. The first task of work is to select the existing video games for exercise one and two that I will be working with.

Literature/Contextual Reviews


Been a while since my last update, so I’ll churn out a few blogs quickly within the next week to make up for it. My main focus over the last week and a half has been the Literature/Contextual Review module which basically requires everyone to pick a topic related to their work and research, analyse and evaluate different methods of research to expand upon our existing knowledge. We are given advice and lectures on Fridays to assist with this module but the lectures are absolute dire and a completely waste of time. They usually revolve around one or maybe two usefully points then the lecturer will just rephrases the same point about 7 or 8 times to drag it out to an hour. Maybe these lectures are useful to other students/courses but to me they are just an utter waste of time. I wanted to make sure I at least take something away from this module so I looked into an area that I would find interesting and usefully towards my work and a subject that would be easy to find plenty of sources for. I looked over my previous blogs to find a relevant subject,  some time back I spoke about the impact video games had on me growing up, the attachment I have for specific games and how they made me felt. I thought an interesting topic would be to explore how video games can produce those reactions in players on demand. So my subject became ‘How can emotion be produced through decision making and player actions?’

Fortunately I had already been reading some design books before I decided to start this essay so I already had some sources I could draw info from.  The assignment required two essays, a Literature and Contextual Review. The Literature Review required 30 sources (10 books, 10 journals and 10 websites) I think it’s a bit unreasonable to expect us to read 10 books in the time span but thankfully it’s easy to jump to relevant sections in most books. Another reason I picked this subject is that it’s pretty easy to find sources related to emotion/player reactions in video games, it becoming such a growing area of interest in the industry at the moment.

I’ve always found it pretty easy to just write and write loads of drivel as I think it up but for this assignment there was a word limit of only 750 words so after the initial flood of words I typed up I probably had to cut out nearly double the actual word limit.

The Contextual essay was easier I found, maybe because it was easy to pick 5 sources from 10 non-word sources than from 30. Most of my contextual sources related with ‘making of’ videos from game developers or interviews with successful creative directors. I attended the Bradford Animation Festivals some days earlier so it seemed only sensible to stick that in my sources as well.

Regardless how well I did or didn’t do I can honestly say not a single Friday morning lecture actually helped or felt relevant to my assignment, which just furthers my dislike for it. Also, we couldn’t even hand our assignments in till about 10:10am (10am deadline) because the tutor was running late, so technically everybody failed anyway.

Sunday, 24 October 2010

Reverse Level Design 2

Like I mentioned in my previous blog, I set myself a warm up project to map out level designs of games already on the market so I could analyse the flow and what parts of the level are easy to communicate and which are difficult. The games I went with are, God of War 3, Left 4 Dead and Oddworld Abe’s Odyssey.

I tried to pick games both different in genre and game style, God of War is adventure/action heavily combat orientated with some puzzles and exploration to break up the action set pieces. One of the things God of War has always been good at is keeping the battles varied and interesting through changing environment obstacles, enemy patterns/routines or simply because the game is great to look at graphically. Some parts of the level were more difficult to map than others, mainly when a puzzle was involved. The puzzle room towards the top of the map became very difficult to explain and show due to the complex nature of the puzzle. 

God of War is renown for it's bloody combat and large scale environments. Battles are often broken up with puzzles revolving around switches and box pushing.

Left 4 Dead I chose because I wanted a first person perspective game and developer Valve are renown FPS game designers so it seemed like a good candidate. Also, I thought it would be interesting as this game is heavily dependent on its co-op nature and the level designs must take into account 4 players will always be present in the game. This game was relevantly easy to map. Unlike the other two games L4D doesn't have many environment interactions or puzzles and is based sorely on the survival combat between the players.

Finally, I chose Oddworld most importantly because it’s 2D and therefore would be designed and communicated in a completely different way to the other two games. From all three of the maps this one is probably the easiest one to communicate. It's also probably the most accurate one for an artist or programmer to pick up as it clearly shows the exact positions of the obstacles whereas the maps for the 3D maps are a bit vague to the specifics and more a 'general design' for the level.

Oddworld is broken up screen by screen, presenting different challenges in each one. 

Saturday, 23 October 2010

Less blog, more work

Right now, I still haven’t nailed down exactly what I want to get from Semester 1. I want my work this year to be appropriate to show employers in a portfolio once I’ve finished my M.A. It would make sense to play on my strengths of mechanics and concepts but it’s becoming more and more obvious that employers are only interested in people with diverse skill set, so I really want to expand my skills in the next year. I’ve considered going back to the dreaded Maya because I think it would help alot in the long run to have that added to my skills. I just wish I had made more effort getting to grips with it in the second and third year of my B.A.

After a discussion on Friday with the M.A course leader and some other M.A students, I’ve sort of got a handle on the direction I want to take. I’m really keen to explore relationships between mechanics and level design. As of yet I’m not sure whether it’s a better idea to create my own mechanics to show off what I can do with my own creations or take the limitations of already existing mechanics and show off what I can do with them. For a while I’ve thought it would be an interesting idea to design levels for existing titles to work within their constraints but I don’t want my M.A. to come up as some ‘fan art/fiction’ instead of something professional that’s going to really impress people when they see it.

I’ve thought I could maybe do a combination, create my own levels and mechanics for my own unique games, taking existing mechanics into a new game and maybe designing levels for an existing game with a new mechanic. I’d like to have as much creative control as I can over my projects because I know, when/if I do get a job in the industry I’ll have little to no real creative control over the titles I work under.

Some games with interesting mechanics/themes;

Dark Cloud/Chronicle – The player collects resources in dungeons to rebuild the villages/towns in the world. NPC can be moved into houses, but some often have requires e.g (one person might want to live next to a river). As part of the story the player must travel into the future versions of their to advance the story.

Majora’s Mask – The player must collect and use a variety of masks to gain different abilities and even transform into different species.

Oddworld – The player can possess enemies and take control of all their actions. The player can also speak with other NPC’s using ‘gamespeak’ shouting introductions to other characters to escape.

Okami – The player controls of a wolf with the abilities to use the ‘Celestial Brush’ to paint stars in the sky, change from night to day, make flowers/trees bloom, slash enemies, draw broken bridges and much more.

Portal – Using a portal gun, the player can create portal entrances and exit points to solve puzzles.

Ape Escape – Using a large net and variety of tools, the objective of each stage to catch a certain number of escaped monkeys.

Shadow of the Colossus – Traversing large open fields, the player must hunt down and kill 16 Colossi, massive, boss like creatures which the player must climb to stab its weak points.

Wind Waker  - Sailing large open world on the sea, taking control of the wind directions to solve puzzles and sail.

Tuesday, 19 October 2010

Reverse Level Design 1

My main goals this year are to develop my communication skills as a level/game designer. I feel confident enough in my abilities to create game concepts and mechanics so this year will be about developing my skills to make those concepts and mechanics actually mean something. Research seems pretty limited in terms of actual level designing; there are few books available to me and even fewer examples of professional industry work. At the moment it seems like I’m going to have to do everything by myself.

The books I have been reading are based more around design philosophies and how to evocate a reaction in the player. They provide great information and advice in general games design experience but again, little to nothing in terms of actually describing the best way to communicate level concept/designs to other people.

When actually playing a game everything is tightly bound together, the sound, art direction, the design and programming all mesh together to create a virtual world in which the player steps into. Trying to look at one of these separately can be tricky with all the other distractions around them.  I was lucky enough to come across The Art of Halo: Creating a Virtual World, which had some of Bungie’s very earlier level design sketches. It’s great to see the first stages of creation, when something went from nothing to something.

Taken from The Art of Halo, Original sketch concepts of levels from Bungie's Halo series.
This inspired a good warm up exercise related to my M.A project, instead of creating a concept on paper with the intention of it being developed into a real game I would do the opposite. I would take an existing game and take it back to the development stages. There are a few reasons for this. First, it will allow me to see that even the most visually impressive game, look exactly the same on paper as a cheap one. Second, it will allow me to see ‘the flow’ of level more clearly, how they are broken up into different gameplay sections. And thirdly, it will let me see which areas of the level are difficult to communicate through visuals.  Hopefully I’ll have the results posted on here soon.

Monday, 18 October 2010

Screw the rules I have money!

If you boil it down to the core, video games involve nothing more than holding a cheap piece of plastic, hitting buttons and watching shapes on your TV react. Even the most artistic, breathtaking, expensive games boil down to the same principles. The actions on screen only become a game when they are given context and context in video games is all about rules. So by definition there is nothing that separates indie or retail games other than their budgets and production values. They are both a collection of rules the player must abide by.

From my experience all games have two types on rules, generic or game specific. Generic rules are the rules that we don’t even think about. For example, in the majority of games the player and the game world abide by the laws of gravity. The player sticks to the ground and falls if they step off a ledge. These are rules that go without saying, the rules that we live by in our real everyday life.  Occasionally a game may change generic rules for the sake of gameplay but generally speaking they are rules commonly found in all games.

Game specific rules are the rules which make up the game itself; these rules are the constraints put on the player and the rules on how beat or lose the game. The game mechanics are the tools for the player to operate within these rules. Take any FPS for example, the rules of the game state if you are shot by an enemy a certain amount of times you will die. The weapons and abilities for you to defend yourself with are the mechanics.

Good game design should be efficient, making the most of the limitations and tools the designers have to work with. Efficient game design is using few game mechanics and using those mechanics in surprising ways, coming up with bizarre obstacles that use the mechanics in more than one way. Take for example, some classic multiplayer FPS’ (I’ll use Halo Reach as my example as I’ve played that recently).

The rules/mechanics are pretty straight forward, you point gun at bad guy and press button till it dies and the enemy does the same to you. You can pick up certain items/weapons, you can jump and crouch. These are the mechanics of the game; in most FPS’s there are different rules for different game types. 
Capture the flag adds no new mechanics to the game but instead changes the rules of play entirely. The game is no longer about killing for points but instead stealing and escaping. Similarly Halo Reach’s ‘Infection’ mode is another great example of this. The rules of the game split the players into Infected or Regular players. The infected players are forced to use the Sword weapon only capable of killing the regular players up close. Once killed by an infected player regular players become infected. No mechanics are added to Halo Reach for these game modes. Instead it is a simple adjustment of the game rules to make the game almost, entirely new.

Oddball, Infection and Capture the Flag are just a few of the game modes in Halo Reach.

There are some great games which bend the rules of their world, fully utilizing all the game’s resources and mechanics. It might just be a personal preference but these are often the sort of games that impress me the most, there’s nothing less fun then having the same dreary challenge again and again for 8 hours till the credits roll.

I recently purchased Limbo, from Playdead Studios an indie game studio based in Denmark. Limbo is a great example of coming up with creative obstacles in an otherwise restricted game. The game has a surprisingly small amount of inputs, the player can move left or right, they can jump and they can grab objects. That’s it. Despite this the game rarely ever slacks, it consistently throws unique and clever traps at you without having to add any extra moves. For indie developers this seems like the  most efficient way to design a good game. Other indie games which use minimal game mechanics in place of sophisticated obstacles and level designs are Splosion Man, Critter Crunch and Angry Birds.

Giant spiders, serious business.

This isn’t to say that games with plenty of mechanics aren’t good, they are very different types of games. Metal Gear Solid 4 has heaps of gadgets, weapons and mechanics so much in fact I didn’t even discover some on the moves until my second or third playthrough. MGS4 was great in alot of ways because it allowed the player to play the how THEY wanted, the players was given an objective, some tools to complete those objectives and that was it. It’s admirable in alot of ways as this much freedom gives the player a sense of accomplishment when they beat the game in their own way. 

Having said that, sometimes too many mechanics can make the game feel like a mess. With MGS4 it was warranted due to the ambiguity of the gameplay. In Darksiders, the game had almost an overwhelming amount of features and equipment to the point some of the button inputs became absurd. 

Anyway wrapping up, last year I made alot of effort to make sure I made the most of the mechanics and features I designed in my games. Different rules, and mechanics have different requirements depending on the game. Whilst a huge amount of skill, time and money goes into making open world games it’s a bit of cop out in a way to just let the player decide what to do and not present any interesting obstacles for them to overcome. My work this year will revolve around making efficient level designs based around a few good simple mechanics.